The Watcher has a shocking, twisty, and surprisingly ambiguous ending, but what is the secret meaning beneath the hit Netflix thriller's finale?
Warning: Spoilers for the Netflix series The Watcher!The ending of Netflix’s The Watcher has proved divisive, yet the series' ambiguous coda has a hidden secret meaning. The Watcher is a Ryan Murphy miniseries loosely based on the true story of 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey. Naomi Watts and Bobby Cannavale play the fictionalized couple Nora and Dean Braddock, who move into a new home with their family and then begin receiving anonymous threatening letters warning them against making any alterations to the house.
The Watcher takes many major liberties with its real-life inspiration. Most of the story depicted on screen is fiction, outside the mysterious letters, the location of the house, and the paranoia and trauma that they caused for the couple involved. After seemingly revealing that the titular threat is Theodora (Noma Dumezweni), a private investigator whom the Braddocks have hired, the series finale of The Watcher ends without ever revealing the true identity of the letter-writer. In this regard, The Watcher is true to the real-life story upon which the show is based, as the case remains unsolved to this day.
What Happens In The Watcher’s Ending?
At the end of The Watcher, the characters Nora and Dean Braddock discover that their private investigator, Theodora, has been hospitalized with cancer. In what seems like a classic twisty ending to a Netflix mystery show, the dying Theodora admits that she was the one who sent the letters. She explains that she had bought 657 Boulevard because it was her dream home, only to be forced to sell it when she couldn’t afford the place. When her husband died, she realized he had hidden away over $1 million. Thus, she could in fact afford the house, leading her to concoct a bizarre scheme to pen threatening letters in order to convince the Braddocks to leave the house.
Why Did Theodora Claim She Was The Watcher?
Theodora explains she hired actors to play the pig-tailed woman who appeared in Dean and Nora’s bedroom, all in an attempt to get her house back. However, at Theodora’s funeral, her daughter refutes these claims, and then the Braddocks learn from their neighbor Mo (Margo Martindale, from the cast of Mrs. America) that Theodora never lived in the house. In The Watcher's rare, dark, double twist ending, it turns out that Theodora was lying as she lay dying, trying to give the Braddocks some closure by claiming to be the Watcher since she was never able to uncover the actual assailant who tormented the couple while she was on the case.
What Happened To Karen In 657 Boulevard?
When the ending of The Watcher reveals Theodora was innocent after all, the suspicious realtor Karen (The White Lotus's Jennifer Coolidge) seems to be a prime suspect. She made no secret of the fact that she wanted 657 Boulevard for herself, she could have been the girl in the pigtails, and she could have written the letters that threatened the Braddocks. As a realtor, Karen was also likely to know all about the house’s secret subterranean tunnels and could have used these to scare the Braddocks into moving out. However, like many Ryan Murphy movies and shows, the twist ending of The Watcher completely disproves this theory when Karen does move into 657 Boulevard after the Braddocks leave the house.
She survives about 48 hours in the house before she is chased out by a masked assailant, and in that time, she suffers more than the Braddocks did during their entire residence in the house. The reason that Karen’s dog is killed and why she receives a letter from the Watcher is so that The Watcher’s ending can firmly disprove the possibility of her being the title villain. Since Karen is the most obvious suspect, her traumatic experience is necessary to make it clear that The Watcher’s ending removes any lingering suspicion from her character.
Was John Graff A Real Person?
Like many true-crime shows on Netflix, The Watcher plays fast and loose with the facts of the case that it is based on. Despite what some sources claim, John Graff was not a real person. The character is based on real-life murderer John List, who did tragically kill his family in Westfield, New Jersey. However, List had nothing to do with the 657 Boulevard case and no connection to the story, making John Graff a fictional creation with a grim real-life inspiration. The reason that The Watcher’s ending adds Graff to the show’s list of characters is likely to accentuate comparisons between the real-life story and more explicitly supernatural scary stories, such as The Amityville Horror.
Is Dean Braddock Becoming The Watcher In The End?
Dean Braddock’s inability to save his family from the Watcher causes the character to obsess over the villain, leading his and Nora’s marriage into trouble. Like Jack Torrance in The Shining or George Lutz, the patriarch of the unfortunate family seen in The Amityville Horror, Dean Braddock eventually flirts with outright madness by the time The Watcher’s dark ending rolls around. During a therapy session, he brings up the house unprompted, and, when he tells Nora he is at a job interview, he secretly revisits 657 Boulevard and watches the new inhabitants of the house as they collect their mail. However, this doesn’t mean Dean is now the Watcher.
For one thing, Dean doesn’t do anything actively malevolent. For another, Nora also visits the house immediately after he leaves, meaning she also hasn’t been able to let go of the events that transpired there. Most importantly, although The Watcher follows Netflix's true crime show protocol and changes a lot of facts, the show is still based on a real-life case, and the real people involved weren’t accused of fabricating the letters, nor did they torment the next inhabitants of the home. As such, even with its fictionalized elements, it would be too much for The Watcher’s ending to imply otherwise.
What The Watcher’s Ending Really Means
The Watcher’s ending is not as straightforward as those of many other Netflix shows, but that is only because it is based on a real-life unsolved case. The lack of resolution in the real-life story is the primary reason that The Watcher’s ending can’t simply unmask its villain. However, the other reason that the Netflix hit can’t have a tidy conclusion is that The Watcher is about the terror of not knowing your neighbor, of never being sure who you live near and what they are up to, and of the impact that a culture of anonymity has on small communities. The Watcher casts suspicion on almost all of its cast and exonerates almost none of them precisely so that the Netflix show can prove that there is no knowing who the Watcher was, and that might be the scariest ending of all.
Next: No One Gets Out Alive Ending Explained (What's Inside The Box?)
